@woohyun @eagleeye is this needed right now or are widgets relying on their own scrollers? scroll_manager works well.

It is necessary to replace elm.scroller widget.

Yes, but is it actually going to be used or will scrolling be implemented directly by widgets (such as collectionview, listview, gridview, ...)?

@zmike

I cannot catch well your point.

Legacy elm_scroller is something that can contains everything what application wants - and this efl_ui_scroller is an alternative for that.

So, I think that efl_ui_scroller would be used a lot from application directly.

Let me know if I am not understanding well about your point.

Scroller itself is a widget container. It holds other widgets and scrolls them.

There is also the ability to implement scrolling directly inside widgets, for example in lists. A list widget does not need to be inside a scroller because it can scroll. So for example, if you have a series of images packed into a box widget, you would put the box into a scroller to provide scrolling since a box cannot scroll, and you would need this class.

I am just making sure that there is a direct demand to have this class stable in this release.

@zmike

It has been used directly with variety cases in Tizen as a basic widget class.
So, I really hope to make it stable for this release.

Alright, just checking.

@zmike

Thanks for checking, and let me know if you need any help on this task.

@eagleeye

Please take a look at this task together.

I don't see a problem with this class currently.